The Truth About the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam


TitleCopyrightContentsAbout The AuthorForewordIslam Faces Danger From Within and OutsideA Terrible Conspiracy Against the Islamic WorldDefining the Terms: “Muslim” and “Apostate”Dissent Among the Ulema on the Definition of a “Muslim”The Definition of a Muslim According to the Holy Prophet (sas)The First Definition by the Holy Prophet (sas)The Second Definition by the Holy Prophet (sas)The Third Definition by the Holy Prophet (sas)Lame Excuse by the UlemaA Definition Concocted by the UlemaThe Definition Concocted by Maulana MaududiDefining ApostasyA Great Subtlety in the Wisdom of GodNobody Has the Right to Call Anyone a “Kafir”The Holy Quran’s Verdict on the Idea of Capital Punishment for an ApostateFirst Verse:Second Verse:Third Verse:Two Important DeclarationsFourth Verse:Analysis of the Self-Styled “Quranic Arguments” Put Forward by the UlemaFirst Argument of UlemaMutilated FactsFurther Examination of the Argument of ‘Uthmani SahibDetails of the Incident According to the Holy QuranThe Meaning of “Slaying One’s Own Soul”Divergence Between the Narratives of the Torah and the Holy QuranMetaphorical “Slaying”Opinions of the Earlier ExegetesUlema’s Second ArgumentAnalysis of Maududi’s InterpretationThe Genuine ContextThe Command Is: “Tuqatiluna” and Not “Taqtuluna”The Third Argument by the UlemaThe Opinion of a Great Exegete of the Indian Sub-ContinentOpinion of a Judge of Pakistan’s Sharia CourtThe Fourth Argument by the UlemaThe Holy Quran’s Stand Concerning ApostatesThe First Verse:The Holy Prophet (sas) And His Companions (ra) Knew Who Were the ApostatesMessenger of God’s Treatment of the Chief of the ApostatesThe Second Verse:The Third Verse:The Fourth Verse:A Crooked ReasoningThe Fifth Verse:The Sixth Verse:The Seventh Verse:The View of Death Penalty for Apostasy in the Light of AhadithAhadith Adopted by the Supporters of Death Penalty for ApostasyThe First HadithAnother IncidentSecond HadithThird TraditionThe Siddiqi Era and ApostasyThe Reality of the So-Called “Siddiqi Sunna”Historical Verification of the Revolt by the ApostatesStrange Point Worth NotingThe Killing of a Female ApostateA Tradition From the Faruqi EraThe Methodology to Measure Soundness of NarrationsThe Apostate Was a FighterA Tradition of the ‘Ali (ra) Era:Investigation of the TraditionThe Narrator Is a KharjiTextual TestimonyFigurative Meaning of “Qatl” (Killing) In Lexicons:The Ahadith That Refute the Death Penalty for ApostasyEarly Ulema and the Concept of ApostasyThe Claim of Ijma‘ Is IncorrectFirst Argument:Second Argument:Third Argument:Fourth Argument:Fifth Argument:Sixth Argument:Opinions of the Present Day UlemaIs Maulana Maududi Serious?The Objectives of the MullahsOld WaysAn Important ExcerptMaududi’s RigidityApostasy and the History of the Prophets (as)The Beliefs of the Enemies of the Prophets (as)Hazrat Nuh (as) Was Accused of Becoming an ApostateVerdict of Apostasy Against Hazrat Ibrahim (as)Hazrat Salih (as) Was Called an ApostateThe Calumniation of Apostasy on Hazrat Shu‘Aib (as)Allegation Against Hazrat Musa (as) By the Nation of the Pharaoh:Reasoning of the Government of PakistanThe Revelation of the Promised Messiah (as)My ReplyThe Allegation of Apostasy Against the Chief of Prophets (sas)You Are Devoid of Shame!The Question IsThe Times Have ChangedThe Miracle of Holy Prophet’s Prayer